Welcome the Fall issue of The Pulse
This issue runs from the bargaining table to the discipline tribunal – 54 decisions across six jurisdictions, and a familiar number holding its ground.
The 3.5% service-sector wage norm we tracked in the Summer edition held through every long-term care and retirement home renewal this quarter. The exception is the one worth watching: the ONA central award for the Participating Nursing Homes came in at 2.25% and 2.00%, the first sector-wide nursing outcome below 3.5%, tracking hospital settlements rather than the service pattern.
The rest of the quarter turned on proof and process. In the hospital sector, the COVID-19 vaccination terminations split on the Employment Standards Act – just cause in both cases, but termination and severance pay turning on how each hospital ran the dismissals – and a 26-year ICU nurse lost her job for overriding a physician’s medication orders. The Prairies produced a run of professional-discipline and human-rights rulings, with Alberta’s tribunal repeatedly sending unionized employees’ complaints to arbitration under Horrocks. In British Columbia, nine decisions turned on what the record showed, from contemporaneous performance notes to a word dropped at the bargaining table. And on the East Coast, the Labour Board and a privacy commissioner drew lines around essential services and health-record access. If you have questions about any of the matters covered, please reach out to a member of our team.
OUR OFFICES
Canada’s only coast-to-coast management-side labour & employment law firm
54
DECISIONS
SUMMARIZED
6
JUDRISDICTIONS
COVERED
3.5%
THE NUMBER
THAT KEEPS HOLDING
ONTARIO • HLDAA INTEREST ARBITRATION • LTC & RETIREMENT HOMES
COVER REPORT – JULY TO SEPTEMBER 2026
3.5% Holds for Service Workers – but the Nurses’ Central Award Breaks Below
The 3.5% service norm held through every one of this quarter’s retirement home and long-term care renewals, with boards again refusing employers’ invitation to treat easing inflation as a reason to depart. The real news is the ONA central award for the Participating Nursing Homes – 2.25% for 2026 and 2.00% for 2027, the first sector-wide outcome below 3.5%, rejecting hospital parity for the fifth consecutive round. Elsewhere the sector lines hold: no retirement home award carried the 1% mid-term increase, and at Hope Street Terrace the $3.00 PSW wage enhancement was folded permanently into the grid.
18
DECISIONS
SUMMARIZED
3.5%
SERVICE NORM
BOTH SECTORS
2.25 / 2.00
ONA CENTRAL AWARD
2026 / 2027
5th
ROUND HOSPITAL
PARITY REJECTED
ONTARIO • HOSPITALS • GRIEVANCE & HRTO
When the Evidence Decides
11 decisions
ONTARIO • HOSPITALS • HLDAA INTEREST ARBITRATION
Replication, Not Duplication
2 decisions
ONTARIO • PARAMEDIC & EMS
Caught on Camera
Can an employer use third-party security video to discipline paramedics? An arbitrator upholds the practice – but leaves every individual use open to challenge on its own facts, with the Charter now in play for public-sector workplaces.
ACROSS THE COUNTRY • PROVINCIAL CASE LAW UPDATE
10 CASES
Ten decisions circling one question: how far an institution’s responsibility actually reaches. Two physicians faced discipline – one for a six-year masquerade as a “psychiatrist” he was never certified to be. The Labour Board held that an employer cannot hide behind a harassing physician’s independent status; the human rights tribunal repeatedly sent unionized employees’ complaints to arbitration under Horrocks, added an owner-director personally after his company was struck from the registry, and found a cardiac surgeon was never AHS’s employee. Two arbitrators held employers to the plain text of their agreements, and the Court of King’s Bench upheld Alberta’s youth gender-affirming surgery ban against a division-of-powers challenge.
9 CASES
Nine decisions spanning human rights, professional regulation, judicial review and the Labour Relations Board – with a recurring lesson in how much the record decides. A perceived-disability complaint turned on contemporaneous notes; a paramedic’s retaliation claim on a documented discipline history; a remote-work grievance on a word dropped at the bargaining table; and a triage-coordinator unit dispute on what the job posting actually required. Alongside them, bigger structural questions – whether a new private care home was a successor employer, whether a 76% essential-services level unlocks first-contract arbitration, and whether the province’s two-stream residency match and its return-of-service contracts can stand.
2 CASES
Two Atlantic decisions, each turning on where a line should be drawn. In Nova Scotia, the Labour Board delivered the latest instalments in the EMC-CUPW paramedic-dispatch dispute: it refused to treat a weakened lockout as grounds for interest arbitration, then set the pay rules for employees working under an essential-services agreement during a strike. In Newfoundland and Labrador, the Privacy Commissioner found a health authority’s safeguards adequate but recommended that employers disclose the name of an employee who snoops in a patient’s record.
1 CASE
A Saskatoon pharmacist was expelled from the profession for life after pleading guilty to trafficking more than 20,000 oxycodone and Percocet pills through her own pharmacy. She filed no response and never appeared, and the Discipline Committee drew an adverse inference from that silence – imposing permanent removal from the register, a public reprimand and nearly $45,000 in costs. A stark illustration of the oversight risk in sole-proprietor pharmacies.