This report summarizes 18 interest arbitration decisions issued between July and September 2026: 12 retirement home decisions, 5 long-term care home decisions, and one non-HLDAA decision. It opens with a wage award trends analysis comparing these decisions to our report in the Summer Edition of The Pulse. Each case summary sets out the employer and bargaining unit, the term of the collective agreement, the key provisions awarded, and the board’s reasoning.
Wage Award Trends Analysis
Overall Wage Pattern
The 3.5% annual general wage increase (GWI) remains the norm for service bargaining units in both sectors. Boards again rejected employer arguments that easing inflation, rising unemployment, a weaker Ontario economy and 2% public sector settlements justified a departure. The main change this period is the central award between the Participating Nursing Homes and ONA. It awarded 2.25% for 2026 and 2.00% for 2027, which is the first sector-wide outcome in these collections below 3.5%. It applies to registered nursing staff under the ONA central template and tracks hospital outcomes rather than the service sector pattern.
Retirement Homes
- GWI Pattern: Every retirement home renewal awarded 3.5% for each year of the term, including the three-year Briargate term running to December 31, 2026. In Butternut Manor and Parkland on the Glen, Arbitrator Sheehan expressly adopted Arbitrator Gedalof’s finding in Chartwell Avondale. That finding was that the 3.5% pattern solidified even as inflation eased and tariffs arrived, and that it holds to this day.
- Mid-Term 1% Increase: No retirement home award included the additional 1% mid-term increase, so the distinction between the two sectors remains.
- Classification-Specific Adjustments: Special wage adjustments remain common. Most ranged from 1% to 2%, or from $0.25 to $1.00 per hour. Several boards responded to minimum wage pressure by eliminating start rates or rebuilding the wage grid (Leacock, Chartwell Tiffin).
- Pension/RRSP: Retirement savings provisions continue to expand, through new NHRIPP, CLAC and LiUNA pension plans and through higher RRSP matching.
- Premiums and Benefits: Weekend and shift premium increases of $0.10 to $0.15 per hour and vision care increases of $50 to $100 remain the norm.
- First Agreements: In Cedarcroft Place, the first agreement following a change of bargaining agent, the board applied the 3.5% norm from the outset, along with substantial classification adjustments. In Pretty River, the GWI was staged to follow a related SEIU unit.
Long-Term Care Homes
- SEIU Master Pattern: Service units continue to receive the 3.5% / 1.0% / 3.5% structure from the SEIU Master Award, together with $1.00 per hour RPN adjustments capped at the SEIU Extendicare adjusted maximum rate (Tony Stacey, Belmont House, Hope Street Terrace).
- RNs: RN units track ONA outcomes. That means a 3% / 3% grid at Tony Stacey and hospital parity by July 2027 at the newly charitable Wiigwas.
- Central ONA Award: The Participating Nursing Homes award rejected hospital parity for the fifth consecutive round and set increases below the service sector pattern.
- Permanent Wage Enhancement: At Hope Street Terrace, the PSW wage enhancement was rolled permanently into the wage grid before the GWI was applied.
Part A: Retirement Homes
1. Briargate Retirement Residence v SEIU, Local 1 Canada
CanLII Citation: 2026 CanLII 71118 (ON LA)
Date: July 14, 2026
Arbitrators
Christopher Albertyn (Chair)
Simran Prihar (Union Nominee)
Robert Kelly (Employer Nominee)
Description of Employer
Briargate Retirement Residence is a 66-suite retirement home in Amherstview, Ontario, west of Kingston, with room for 68 residents. It is managed by Levante Living.
Employees Covered
41 employees in the Cook, Housekeeper, Maintenance, Aide, PSW, Recreation Aide, RPN and Server classifications.
Duration of Collective Agreement
January 1, 2024 to December 31, 2026 (three-year renewal agreement, agreed by the parties)
What Was Awarded
- General wage increases of 3.5% on January 1 of each of 2024, 2025 and 2026. Aides received their second increase on October, 1, 2024 to stay ahead of minimum wage.
- Special wage increases after the award of $0.50/hr for RPNs, $0.25/hr for PSWs and $0.25/hr for Aides.
- Meal period language amended to compensate night shift employees who are required to remain in the building.
- A float holiday replaced with Family Day.
- The six-week vacation entitlement now begins after 23 years of service.
- Vision care increased to $350 every 24 months.
- In-lieu premium increased by $0.10/hr.
Rationale
The board applied replication along with comparability, total compensation and demonstrated need. It gave particular weight to comparable unionized retirement residences. The timing of the special wage increases was a specific point of dispute.
Dissents
Both nominees partially dissented.
2. Georgian Traditions (Retirement Home) v SEIU, Local 1 Canada
CanLII Citation: 2026 CanLII 77265 (ON LA)
Date: July 15, 2026
Arbitrators
John Stout (Chair)
Terry McCarthy (Employer Nominee)
Wassim Garzouzi (Union Nominee)
Description of Employer
Georgian Traditions is a 100-suite retirement home in Collingwood, Ontario.
Employees Covered
About 45 employees in the RPN, PSW, Chef/Cook, UCP/MCR, Activity Aide, Guest Attendant, Dietary and Housekeeping Aide, and Receptionist/Concierge classifications.
Duration of Collective Agreement
April 12, 2024 to April 11, 2026 (two-year renewal agreement)
What Was Awarded
- General wage increases of 3.5% on April 12, 2024 and April 12, 2025.
- New self-isolation language allowing employees to use sick leave, vacation or lieu time when self-isolation is required.
- New afternoon premium of $0.15/hr.
- Weekend and night shift premiums each increased by $0.10/hr.
- Vision and paramedical coverage each increased by $50.
- Pension contribution increased by 1%.
Rationale
The board applied the HLDAA criteria and the principles of total compensation, demonstrated need and gradualism. Above all, it applied replication informed by objective comparative evidence. It noted that replication is a contextual exercise, and that interest arbitrators “interpret the collective bargaining scene” rather than “sit in judgment of its results.”
Dissents
Both nominees dissented in part.
3. CUPE and its Local 4987 v WC Operating (Ontario-2) LP o/a Bough Beeches Place
CanLII Citation: 2026 CanLII 72197 (ON LA)
Date: July 15, 2026
Arbitrators
Jesse Kugler (Chair)
Jeffrey Sack, K.C. (Union Nominee)
Bob Kelly (Employer Nominee)
Description of Employer
Bough Beeches Place is a for-profit, 98-suite retirement home in Mississauga, Ontario.
Employees Covered
About 64 employees in the RPN, PSW, Housekeeping, Dietary, Cook, Activities and Resident Support classifications.
Duration of Collective Agreement
January 29, 2025 to January 28, 2027 (two-year renewal agreement, as the parties could not agree on term)
What Was Awarded
- General wage increases of 3.5% on January 29, 2025 and January 29, 2026.
- Special wage adjustments of $0.60/hr for PSWs and $0.35/hr for Housekeeping, Dietary and Laundry staff, effective the first full pay period after the award.
- Weekend premium increased from $0.10 to $0.20/hr.
- The employer’s pregnancy and parental leave proposal was sent back to the parties, with the board remaining seized.
Rationale
The board applied the HLDAA criteria and the principles of comparability, demonstrated need, total compensation and gradualism, which it described as putting “flesh on the bones of replication.”
Dissents
Both nominees concurred in part.
4. Pretty River Retirement Residence v SEIU, Local 1 Canada
CanLII Citation: 2026 CanLII 75553 (ON LA)
Date: July 27, 2026
Arbitrators
Christopher Albertyn (Chair)
Simran Prihar (Union Nominee)
Robert Kelly (Employer Nominee)
Description of Employer
Pretty River is a 36-suite, 42-resident retirement home in Raglan Village, Collingwood, Ontario. It opened in 2023 and has a secure unit for residents living with Alzheimer’s and dementia.
Employees Covered
An all-employee unit of PSWs, RPNs, Cooks, Housekeeping and Recreation Assistants. The union was certified on December 9, 2024.
Duration of Collective Agreement
December 20, 2024 to December 31, 2026 (first collective agreement, agreed term)
What Was Awarded
- General wage increases of 0.5% on January 1, 2025, 1.75% on July 1, 2025 and 3.5% on January 1, 2026.
- Weekend premium of $0.15/hr.
- Uniform allowance of $0.06/hr.
- Vision coverage of $300 every 24 months.
- Part-time employees scheduled under 48 hours bi-weekly receive $0.20/hr in lieu of benefits, plus employer-paid life insurance of $15,000.
- The RRSP will be replaced with the NHRIPP at 1% matching contributions within six months of the award.
Rationale
The wage schedule reflected three things: a 3% increase the employer paid in July 2024 before certification, the parties’ agreement that the 2024 rate was 3.5%, and their agreement to move the annual increase date from July to January. The delayed 3.5% increase for 2026 mirrors the related SEIU unit at Raglan Village.
Dissents
Both nominees partially dissented.
5. UFCW Canada, Local 175 v The Colonial Retirement Home 1187652 Ontario Limited
CanLII Citation: 2026 CanLII 79918 (ON LA)
Date: July 30, 2026
Arbitrators
Jesse Kugler (Chair)
Wassim Garzouzi (Union Nominee)
Terry McCarthy (Employer Nominee)
Description of Employer
The Colonial Retirement Home is a for-profit, 96-suite retirement home in Whitby, Ontario. It was recently bought by Prima Living, which operates 12 other homes in Ontario.
Employees Covered
About 46 full-time, part-time and casual PSWs and Dietary Aides.
Duration of Collective Agreement
March 1, 2025 to February 28, 2027 (two-year renewal agreement, as the parties could not agree on term)
What Was Awarded
- General wage increases of 3.5% on March 1, 2025 and March 1, 2026.
- Employer RRSP match increased from 2% to 3%, effective the date of the award.
- Retroactive pay due within three pay periods.
Rationale
The board applied the HLDAA criteria and the principles of comparability, demonstrated need, total compensation and gradualism. It warned that a party that “cherry picks” comparator data and presents only a partial picture risks its credibility. In the board’s view, parties should disclose all arguably relevant comparator data and then argue about how much weight it deserves.
Dissents
Both nominees dissented in part. The employer nominee found the total compensation too high.
6. Georgian Bay Seniors Lodge by MyLife Retirement v SEIU, Local 1 Canada
CanLII Citation: 2026 CanLII 79449 (ON LA)
Date: August 5, 2026
Arbitrators
Eli A. Gedalof (Chair)
Ryan Wood (Employer Nominee)
Simran Prihar (Union Nominee)
Description of Employer
Georgian Bay Seniors Lodge is an 84-suite retirement home in Penetanguishene, Ontario.
Employees Covered
About 38 full-time and part-time Cooks, Housekeeping staff, PSWs, UCPs, Dietary staff and a Maintenance Lead Hand. The union was certified on February 15, 2017.
Duration of Collective Agreement
July 22, 2024 to July 21, 2026 (two-year renewal agreement)
What Was Awarded
- General wage increases of 3.5% on July 22, 2024 and July 22, 2025, with retroactive pay due within four pay periods.
- RPN special wage adjustment of $1.00/hr, effective the date of the award.
- Dietary Aide/Server and Housekeeping rates set at $17.50 (July 22, 2024) and $18.10 (July 22, 2025), inclusive of the GWI.
- Dietary Aide Student classification removed.
- NHRIPP introduced at 1%, effective October 1, 2026.
- New weekend premium of $0.15/hr.
- Other benefits unchanged, with a new $225 annual Health Care Spending Account effective October 1, 2026.
Rationale
The board applied the HLDAA criteria and the principles of replication, comparability, total compensation and demonstrated need. Because the agreement has no wage grid and has already expired, the board directed the parties to address the grid in the next round of bargaining.
Dissents
Both nominees dissented in part.
7. Chartwell Allandale Retirement Residence v CLAC Local 304
CanLII Citation: 2026 CanLII 81826 (ON LA)
Date: August 10, 2026
Arbitrators
Matthew Wilson (Chair)
Terry McCarthy (Employer Nominee)
Shalom Schachter (Union Nominee)
Description of Employer
Allandale Station is a 142-suite retirement home in Barrie, Ontario, owned and operated by Chartwell.
Employees Covered
About 82 employees. CLAC was certified on March 23, 2023.
Duration of Collective Agreement
April 1, 2025 to March 31, 2027 (first renewal agreement)
What Was Awarded
- General wage increases of 3.5% on April 1, 2025 and April 1, 2026.
- Special adjustment of 2% for the Dining Room Server, Dietary Aide, Housekeeper and Receptionist classifications, effective October 1, 2025.
- Weekend premium increased by $0.10/hr.
- Shift premium increased by $0.10/hr and renamed the Night Shift Premium.
- New evening shift premium of $0.10/hr for hours between 15:00 and 23:00.
- New CLAC pension plan with mandatory 1% employer and 1% employee contributions, effective 60 days after the award.
- New in-lieu payment of 2% for part-time employees who are not eligible for benefits.
- Paramedical benefit increased to $400.
Rationale
The board accepted that the agreement lags behind its comparators. Because this was a first renewal, it applied gradualism and introduced new benefits at modest starting levels. It found that replication and comparability made a compelling case for 3.5% in each year. The special adjustments were delayed to October 1, 2025 to reduce the cost to the employer.
Dissents
Both nominees dissented. The employer nominee would have shown more restraint on the pension and in-lieu payment. The union nominee argued that the award did not restore lost purchasing power, gave too little weight to retention, and wrongly refused to stay seized on WSIB coverage pending Bill 105.
8. Chartwell Tiffin Retirement Residence v OPSEU, Local 395
CanLII Citation: 2026 CanLII 81615 (ON LA)
Date: August 10, 2026
Arbitrators
Eli A. Gedalof (Chair)
Terry McCarthy (Employer Nominee)
Marcelle Goldenberg (Union Nominee)
Description of Employer
Chartwell Tiffin is a retirement home in Midland, Ontario, with 44 assisted living suites and 29 memory care suites.
Employees Covered
About 77 full-time, regular part-time and casual Activity Aides, Cooks, Aides (Dietary/Server/Housekeeping), General Aides/PSWs, Receptionists and a Driver.
Duration of Collective Agreement
March 1, 2025 to February 28, 2027 (second collective agreement)
What Was Awarded
- Rebuilt wage grid, with grid adjustments followed by general wage increases of 3.5% on March 1, 2025 and March 1, 2026.
- Special wage adjustments, effective the date of the award.
- Part-time and casual in-lieu payment increased to 4%.
- Overtime threshold lowered from 88 to 75 hours bi-weekly, or 7.5 hours per day.
- New $0.50/hr premium for PSWs and GAs assigned med pass duties.
- Retroactive pay due within three full pay periods.
Rationale
The first agreement ran for more than five years with 2% annual increases and no increase in the final year. Over that time, inflation peaked and the minimum wage rose almost 23%. By the time the agreement expired, every classification except Activity Aides and RPNs was paid below minimum wage. The board used the union’s proposed grid as the starting point for rebuilding the wage grid. It did not create the UCP classification the union sought, and instead awarded a med pass premium of a kind that is common among comparators.
Dissents
Both nominees dissented in part. The employer nominee would not have increased the in-lieu payment, given the size of the wage increases.
9. CLAC Local 305 v Cedarcroft Place Retirement Residence
CanLII Citation: 2026 CanLII 81825 (ON LA)
Date: August 12, 2026
Arbitrators
Norm Jesin (Chair)
Shalom Schachter (Union Nominee)
Seann McAleese (Employer Nominee)
Description of Employer
Cedarcroft Place is an 85-suite retirement home in Stratford, Ontario.
Employees Covered
24 full-time and 39 part-time employees. CLAC obtained bargaining rights by displacing the previous union.
Duration of Collective Agreement
January 1, 2024 to December 31, 2025 (first collective agreement, agreed term)
What Was Awarded
- General wage increases of 3.5% on January 1, 2024 and January 1, 2025.
- Classification adjustments, including:
- $0.65/hr for Dietary, Laundry and Housekeeping Aides, plus increases to the grid steps;
- $0.75/hr for Resident Attendants;
- further adjustments for Activity Coordinators, Cooks, UCPs and RPNs.
- A holiday converted to Family Day.
- Dental maximum increased to $1,500 and vision to $325.
- Part-time sick leave increased to four days.
- New afternoon shift premium of $0.10/hr.
- Retroactive pay due within three pay periods.
Rationale
The board applied the usual interest arbitration criteria, most notably replication and comparability.
Dissents
Both nominees dissented in part. The union nominee argued that the award did not restore lost purchasing power and should have included a pregnancy top-up. The employer nominee would have awarded smaller special adjustments phased in over a longer period. He also objected to reliance on the employer’s other retirement homes as comparators, since they run on a different fee-for-service model. In his view, the catch-up reflected unique first-contract circumstances and should not be treated as a baseline for future rounds.
10. Leacock Retirement Lodge v Health Care Service Workers Union, CLAC Local 304
CanLII Citation: 2026 CanLII 91871 (ON LA)
Date: September 4, 2026
Arbitrators
Norm Jesin (Chair)
Shalom Schachter (Union Nominee)
Irv Kleiner (Employer Nominee)
Description of Employer
Leacock Retirement Lodge is a 110-bed retirement home in Orillia, Ontario, owned by Jarlette.
Employees Covered
12 attendants (5 full-time and 7 part-time).
Duration of Collective Agreement
August 8, 2024 to August 7, 2026 (two-year renewal agreement)
What Was Awarded
- General wage increases of 3.5% on August 8, 2024 and August 8, 2025.
- Start rates eliminated for the RA 1 and RA 2 classifications, which now progress through steps at start, 3 months, 1 year, 2 years and 3 years.
- New night shift premium of $0.15/hr.
- Life insurance increased to $25,000 and vision care to $350.
- Pension contributions increased to 3%.
- New in-lieu payment of $0.10/hr for part-time employees.
- Paid meal break for employees required to remain on site.
- Reimbursement cap for medical certificates increased to $50.
- The panel of arbitrators Letter of Understanding was sent back to the parties.
Rationale
The board applied the s. 9(1.1) HLDAA criteria, most notably replication and comparability.
Dissents
Both nominees dissented in part. The union nominee argued that the award did not restore lost purchasing power or correct the lower total hourly compensation paid to part-time employees who do the same work as full-time employees.
11. Butternut Manor Retirement Living v LiUNA, Local 3000
CanLII Citation: 2026 CanLII 98371 (ON LA)
Date: September 22, 2026
Arbitrators
Brian Sheehan (Chair)
Ryan Wood (Employer Nominee)
Wassim Garzouzi (Union Nominee)
Description of Employer
Butternut Manor is a for-profit retirement home in Uxbridge, Ontario, with room for 66 residents. They range from highly mobile residents to those living with dementia.
Employees Covered
Full-time, part-time and casual RPNs, UCPs, Care Attendants, Cooks, Front Desk/Dietary staff and Housekeeping. This is the parties’ second collective agreement.
Duration of Collective Agreement
June 1, 2024 to May 31, 2026 (two-year renewal agreement)
What Was Awarded
- General wage increases of 3.5% on June 1, 2024 and June 1, 2025.
- Special adjustments effective the date of the award:
- 1% for the RPN, Care Attendant, Server and Housekeeping classifications;
- 2% for the UCP, Cook, Front Desk/Activation and Maintenance Assistant classifications.
- Retroactive pay due within four pay periods.
- Overtime threshold lowered from 80 to 75 hours bi-weekly.
- Employer discretion to recognize prior related experience when placing RPNs on the grid.
- Weekend premium increased by $0.10/hr and vision coverage by $100.
- New 1% employer contribution to the Labourers’ Central and Eastern Canada Pension Plan, with employees able to elect to match it.
Rationale
The employer pointed to falling inflation, financial difficulties and the absence of any recruitment problem. Even so, the board found that replication strongly supported the normative 3.5% increases and some special adjustments. It adopted Arbitrator Gedalof’s reasoning in Chartwell Avondale that the 3.5% pattern solidified over the same period that economic conditions softened. It said the size of the special adjustments and the modest benefit improvements reflected total compensation.
Dissents
The employer nominee would not have awarded any special adjustments. The union nominee dissented in part.
12. Parkland on the Glen v SEIU, Local 1 Canada
CanLII Citation: 2026 CanLII 98372 (ON LA)
Date: September 22, 2026
Arbitrators
Brian Sheehan (Chair)
Ryan Wood (Employer Nominee)
Wassim Garzouzi (Union Nominee)
Description of Employer
Parkland on the Glen is a retirement home in Mississauga, Ontario, owned and operated by Shannex RLC Limited.
Employees Covered
About 69 employees (24 full-time, 26 part-time and 19 casual) in the Dishwasher, Server, Cook, UCP, PSW, RPN, Suite Service Attendant, Housekeeping Heavy Duty and Maintenance classifications.
Duration of Collective Agreement
January 14, 2025 to January 13, 2027 (two-year renewal agreement)
What Was Awarded
- General wage increases of 3.5% on January 14, 2025 and January 14, 2026.
- Special wage adjustment of 2% for all classifications, effective the date of the award.
- Afternoon shift premium increased by $0.10.
- Vision care increased by $100 to $400 every 24 months.
- Three weeks of vacation after three years of service.
Rationale
The employer proposed 2% a year, pointing to the end of high inflation, a significant decline in Ontario’s economy and a 2% or lower trend in 2026 hospital and broader public sector settlements. The board found that the normative pattern remains 3.5% a year and again adopted the Chartwell Avondale reasoning. It found the special adjustments justified because such adjustments have been the norm in SEIU retirement home bargaining and because of the wage gap with the employer’s sister home in Etobicoke.
Dissents
The employer nominee would not have awarded any special adjustments. The union nominee dissented in part.
Part B: Long-Term Care Homes
13. Belmont House v SEIU, Local 1 Canada
CanLII Citation: 2026 CanLII 78823 (ON LA)
Date: July 30, 2026
Arbitrators
Brian Sheehan (Chair)
Irv Kleiner (Employer Nominee)
Wassim Garzouzi (Union Nominee)
Description of Employer
Belmont House is a charitable, non-profit long-term care home in Toronto. It has 140 licensed long-term care beds and 81 retirement apartments, and a new tower adding 168 beds is expected to open in fall 2028.
Employees Covered
128 full-time and 107 part-time/casual service employees. SEIU has represented the unit since 1987.
Duration of Collective Agreement
September 16, 2024 to September 16, 2026 (two-year renewal agreement)
What Was Awarded
- General wage increases of 3.5% on September 16, 2024, 1% on February 16, 2025 and 3.5% on September 16, 2025.
- RPN special wage adjustment of $1.00 after the GWI in each year.
- Family Day added as a paid holiday. Any newly proclaimed holiday will replace an existing designated holiday.
- Weekend premium increased by $0.10/hr.
- Vision care increased to $400 every two years.
- Bereavement leave now covers miscarriage and allows a day to be saved for a delayed interment.
- Uniform allowance increased to $0.07/hr.
- Part-time employees accrue sick leave up to 22.5 hours a year. Whether it is paid at 85% or 100% was sent back to the parties.
- At the employer’s request, the billed OHIP premium language and semi-private hospital coverage were deleted.
Rationale
The employer argued that inflation had eased and Ontario’s economic outlook had worsened since the 2024 SEIU Master Award. The board nonetheless found that replication strongly supported following the SEIU Master. It gave weight to the employer’s total compensation argument about existing superior provisions, and left several proposals for the parties’ upcoming bargaining.
Dissents
Both nominees dissented in part.
14. The Participating Nursing Homes v ONA
CanLII Citation: 2026 CanLII 84152 (ON LA)
Date: August 18, 2026
Arbitrators
William Kaplan (Chair)
Irv Kleiner (Employers’ Nominee)
Phil Abbink (Association Nominee)
Description of Employer
The Participating Nursing Homes, a group of 210 Ontario nursing homes bargaining centrally with ONA. This was the 16th round of joint bargaining.
Employees Covered
More than 4,000 RNs and other healthcare staff represented by ONA.
Duration of Collective Agreement
Two-year term, with increases effective July 1, 2026 and July 1, 2027
What Was Awarded
- General wage increases of 2.25% on July 1, 2026 and 2.00% on July 1, 2027.
- RPN adjustment after the July 1, 2026 increase, bringing RPNs at the maximum rate up to the SEIU Master maximum of $35.07, with matching increases to the lower steps.
- Mental health coverage increased to $1,500 a year, and all other paramedical benefits increased by $100 in each year. All employees’ benefits are set at the RN rate.
- All premiums increased by $0.30, effective the date of the award.
- Reporting time is treated as time worked and paid at the rate of the shift just worked.
- Pension eligibility harmonized at 450 hours.
- Salary continuation during quarantine or isolation required by employer policy, law or public health direction.
- The rotation requirement for RPNs and PSWs was eliminated where it exists.
- Casual employees must offer at least two shifts a month, one of them on a weekend.
Rationale
The board rejected ONA’s request for hospital parity, noting that the parties have never agreed to it and no interest arbitration board has awarded it. It described what the parties have done in their voluntary settlements as the best evidence of replication. The employer side pointed to lower settlements, easing inflation, a technical recession, rising unemployment and hospital layoffs, along with strong recruitment results. The board rejected most of the employer’s proposals, including eliminating LTD and imposing “cost containment” on sick leave.
Dissents
Both nominees dissented. The employer nominee would have awarded 2% and 1.5%, in line with the CUPE hospital settlement and the SEIU hospital award. He relied on Ontario’s 7.5% unemployment rate and hospital layoffs. The union nominee argued that the award should have moved closer to parity with Municipal Homes for the Aged and should have included point-of-care flagging of violence risk, and objected to the transfer of accountability language awarded.
15. Tony Stacey Centre for Veterans Care v SEIU, Local 1 Canada
CanLII Citation: 2026 CanLII 87136 (ON LA)
Date: August 20, 2026
Arbitrators
Christopher Albertyn (Chair)
Simran Prihar (Union Nominee)
Robert Kelly (Employer Nominee)
Description of Employer
Tony Stacey Centre for Veterans Care is a not-for-profit, 100-bed long-term care home in Scarborough, Ontario. It specializes in care for veterans and their families and is managed by UniversalCare Canada Inc.
Employees Covered
125 employees in an all-employee unit that includes PSWs, RPNs, RNs, RAI, a Social Worker, Recreation Aides, Cooks, Dietary, Housekeeping, Laundry and Maintenance staff.
Duration of Collective Agreement
October 11, 2024 to October 10, 2026 (two-year renewal agreement)
What Was Awarded
- General wage increases for non-RNs of 3.5% on October 11, 2024, 1% on May 11, 2025 and 3.5% on October 11, 2025.
- New RN wage grid with increases of 3% in each year.
- RPN special wage increases of $1.00/hr after each GWI, capped at the SEIU Extendicare adjusted maximum rate.
- Retroactivity language moved into the collective agreement, with the payment period shortened from 120 to 90 days.
- Bereavement leave amended as both parties proposed: “(or other cultural practices)” added, and “consecutive calendar” added before “days”.
- New central language on paying for non-mandatory in-service sessions.
- Part-time in-lieu payment changed from $0.50/hr to 7.5%, following the Extendicare Central agreement.
- Vision care increased from $350 to $400.
- Medical certificate cost cap removed.
- Sick-call notice language adopted from the SEIU Master.
- The OHSA s. 32 Letter of Understanding was deleted.
Rationale
As both parties recommended, the board treated the SEIU Extendicare Master Agreement as the dominant comparator for service employees. For RNs, it treated the central ONA–Participating Nursing Homes outcomes as the leading comparator. It also recognized areas where these parties have historically agreed to different outcomes.
Dissents
Both nominees partially dissented. The union nominee would not have awarded the employer’s bereavement leave amendment, calling it superfluous.
16. Wiigwas Elder and Senior Care v ONA
CanLII Citation: 2026 CanLII 89876 (ON LA)
Date: August 25, 2026
Arbitrators
Eli A. Gedalof (Chair)
Irv Kleiner (Employer Nominee)
Philip Abbink (Association Nominee)
Description of Employer
Wiigwas Elder and Senior Care is a 96-bed long-term care home in Kenora, Ontario. It was formerly a for-profit participating nursing home, has since become not-for-profit, and has been a registered charity since January 1, 2025.
Employees Covered
About 5 Registered Nurses.
Duration of Collective Agreement
July 1, 2024 to June 30, 2028 (four-year renewal agreement, agreed by the parties)
What Was Awarded
- New RN wage grid with annual increases (top rate of $54.59 at July 1, 2025 and $57.68 at July 1, 2026), and parity with the Central Hospital Agreement effective July 1, 2027, retroactive if not finalized by then.
- Paid sick leave: existing full-time employees receive a 101.25-hour bank, and from July 1, 2027 accrue 1.25 days a month to a maximum of 112.5 hours.
- Shift premium increased to $1.75/hr and weekend premium to $2.00/hr on ratification.
- Benefit improvements, including:
- 100% employer-paid extended health;
- paramedical maximum increased to $1,000;
- mental health coverage increased to $1,000;
- group life insurance at 2x salary;
- 50% employer-paid dental with $2,500 basic coverage;
- $2,000 lifetime orthodontic coverage.
- Percentage in lieu of benefits set at 8.5%.
Rationale
The central issues arose from the home’s change to charitable status. In the charitable sector, the comparators for ONA units are other charitable homes and the ONA Central Hospital rates for RNs. The board balanced moving the home toward normative charitable sector outcomes against gradualism and total compensation.
Dissents
Both nominees dissented in part.
17. Hope Street Terrace (C.V.H. (6) LP) v LiUNA, Local 3000
CanLII Citation: 2026 CanLII 97249 (ON LA)
Date: September 18, 2026
Arbitrators
Sheri Price (Chair)
Wassim Garzouzi (Union Nominee)
Irv Kleiner (Employer Nominee)
Description of Employer
Hope Street Terrace is a 97-resident long-term care home in Port Hope, Ontario. It is one of more than 45 long-term care homes operated by Southbridge Homes.
Employees Covered
About 80 full-time and part-time PSW/HCAs, RPNs, Environmental Services, Housekeeping/Laundry, Dietary, Cooks, Nurses’ Aides, Activity Aides, OT Aides and Handyperson/Maintenance staff.
Duration of Collective Agreement
June 1, 2024 to May 31, 2026 (two-year renewal agreement, renewing automatically each year unless notice is given)
What Was Awarded
- The PSW wage enhancement becomes a permanent part of the wage grid effective June 1, 2024, so the $3.00 is not removed before the GWI is applied.
- General wage increases of 3.5% on June 1, 2024, 1.0% on December 1, 2024 and 3.5% on June 1, 2025.
- RPN special adjustments of $1.00/hr after the June 1, 2025 GWI, and a further $1.00/hr on the RPN grid effective the date of the award.
- Vision increased to $350 every 24 months.
- 100% employer-paid health and dental premiums.
- Weekend premium increased by $0.10/hr.
Rationale
The board applied the s. 9(1.1) HLDAA criteria and the well-established normative criteria.
Dissents
Both nominees dissented in part.
Part C: Other (Non-HLDAA)
The following case was decided by mediation/arbitration that the parties agreed to after a lawful strike, not under HLDAA.
18. Lynwood Charlton Centre v OPSEU
CanLII Citation: 2026 CanLII 78314 (ON LA)
Date: August 3, 2026
Arbitrators
William Kaplan (Sole Arbitrator)
Description of Employer
Lynwood Charlton Centre is a publicly funded children’s mental health agency in Hamilton and the city’s Lead Agency for Child and Youth Mental Health. It is funded by the Ministry of Children, Community and Social Services and the Ministry of Health.
Employees Covered
About 120 employees who provide residential treatment, counselling, behavioural intervention, day treatment, family support, community outreach, case management and specialized services.
Duration of Collective Agreement
April 1, 2024 to March 31, 2028 (four-year term)
What Was Awarded
- Wage increases of 1% on April 1, 2024, 3% on April 1, 2025, a variable increase under a new schedule on April 1, 2026, and 2.5% on April 1, 2027.
- Retroactive pay to current and former employees within 60 days.
- Move to the CAAT DBplus Pension Plan, with participation starting within six months. Employees contribute 2.5% of base earnings and the employer matches. Part-time employees with one year of service participate but may opt out.
- Mileage increased to $0.65/km, effective April 1, 2027.
- A return-to-work protocol agreed alongside the award.
Rationale
The previous agreement expired on March 31, 2024. A lawful strike began on May 25, 2026, and on July 31, 2026 the parties agreed to refer all outstanding issues to mediation/arbitration. The hardest issue was the union’s request for Bill 124 relief, given the employer’s funding constraints. The wage reopener in the expired agreement did not mention Bill 124. It only required the parties to negotiate if additional funding became available. The employer committed to continue advocating for more funding through Children’s Mental Health Ontario and the Lead Agency Consortium.
Dissents
Not applicable (sole arbitrator).
If you have questions about any of these decisions, please contact a member of the Mathews Dinsdale healthcare team.