July – September 2026
Two hospital interest-arbitration decisions this quarter show the central wage pattern holding firm – 3.00% and 2.25% – while the Boards work out the consequences of last year’s awards. The Price Board clarifies that a reduction in paid reporting time will not trigger a layoff, but leaves the leave-pay questions for rights arbitration; and the OPSEU/SEFPO Board declines to extend ONA’s transfer-of-accountability premium to a unit that never bore the same disadvantage.
Trends this quarter
Key observations:
- Implementation Disputes Continue: Last quarter’s report covered Arbitrator Kaplan’s ruling that the Health Care Spending Account is subject to the standard 25% employee cost-sharing requirement. This quarter, the Price Board’s supplementary ONA award resolved disputes over how to implement its September 2025 awards on transfer of accountability (“TOA”) and the nurse practitioner wage grid.
- Central Wage Pattern Holds: Our last report noted that hospital service worker awards were tracking central hospital comparator patterns, with Humber River Health awarded general wage increases of 3.0% + 2.25% following the Central Hospital–SEIU pattern. This quarter, the OPSEU/SEFPO central award applied the same 3.00% and 2.25% increases.
- TOA Ripple Effects: OPSEU/SEFPO argued that the Board should award the same total compensation as ONA, including the 1.75% of compensation attributed to TOA. The Board rejected this argument, finding that the TOA issue was unique to ONA and that its cost did not mean OPSEU/SEFPO should benefit where its members did not suffer the same disadvantage. The Board also relied on the principle that “replication does not mean duplication”.
- Operational Flexibility and Employer Proposals: This quarter, the OPSEU/SEFPO award included a number of hospital proposals aimed at operational flexibility.
Case Summaries
1. The Participating Hospitals v Ontario Nurses’ Association (Supplementary Award)
CanLII Citation: 2026 CanLII 87876 (ON LA)
Date: August 24, 2026
Arbitrators
Sheri Price (Chair)
Brett Christen (Hospitals Nominee)
Philip Abbink (Union Nominee)
Employees Covered
Nurses represented by the Ontario Nurses’ Association at the participating hospitals, under the April 1, 2025 – March 31, 2027 central agreement. This is an implementation dispute arising from the Board’s September 3, 2025 award, not an interest arbitration setting new terms.
The Disputed Clauses
In its September 2025 award, the Price Board amended art. 13.01 to require hospitals to pay nurses for up to 15 minutes of reporting time (transfer of accountability, or “TOA”) beyond the end of the normal daily tour, at the rate of the tour just worked. Reporting time beyond 15 minutes is still paid as overtime. The Board said that it intended to end unpaid reporting time, not to affect other collective agreement entitlements, particularly those based on hours worked. It gave overtime thresholds and callback (art. 14.06) as examples.
In a February 2026 Interim MOA, the parties agreed on 34 provisions to which reporting time does or does not apply, but could not agree on three groups of provisions. The Hospitals sought an order that reporting time does not affect them. ONA’s main position was that the Board lacked jurisdiction. In the alternative, ONA argued that the award did not affect these entitlements and that no amendments were needed. The disputed provisions were:
- 10.08(a), the definition of “layoff”, which includes a reduction in a nurse’s hours of work and cancellation of all or part of a scheduled shift. A layoff triggers job security rights such as bumping and recall.
- Pay during union leaves: “salary” during Union Business leave, Union Board of Directors leave and ONA President leave (arts. 11.02(a), 11.03, 11.04).
- “Regular pay for scheduled hours” during bereavement leave (art. 11.05).
- “Regular pay” and/or “pa[y] for all hours scheduled” during jury and witness duty leave (art. 11.06).
- “Regular earnings from regularly scheduled hours” during education leave (art. 11.09(c)).
- A full-time nurse’s “regular weekly earnings”, used to calculate the Supplemental Unemployment Benefit (SUB) top-up during pregnancy and parental leave (arts. 11.07(f), 11.08(e)).
The Board’s Determinations
- The Board has jurisdiction to determine the remaining disputes about its awards on TOA and NP wages.
- Reporting time of up to 15 minutes beyond the normal daily tour does not apply when determining whether there has been a “layoff” under art. 10.08(a). The parties were directed to make a consequential amendment to give effect to this determination.
- No amendment was directed for arts. 11.02(a), 11.03, 11.04, 11.05, 11.06, 11.07(f), 11.08(e) or 11.09(c). Any dispute about these articles is left to rights arbitration.
- The reference to NPs’ “years of service” in the September 2025 award was not intended to change NP grid placement. Grid placement continues to be governed by the existing terms of the collective agreement.
Rationale – Jurisdiction
The Board held that it was not functus officio, because it had expressly remained seized to resolve disputes over implementing its TOA award. It also held that ss. 9(2) and 10 of HLDAA keep the Board seized of all matters in dispute until a collective agreement is in effect. In reaching this view, the Board relied on the Divisional Court’s decision in Brockville Psychiatric Hospital , [2007] O.J. No. 40. The Board read the parties’ February 2026 MOA as a whole. On that reading, the MOA barred only changes to the amendments the parties had already agreed; it did not prevent the Board from deciding the issues the parties had expressly referred to it.
Rationale – Layoffs
Article 10.08(a) is plainly based on hours of work. The entitlements that flow from a layoff are exactly the kind of hours-based entitlements the Board did not intend to affect, like the overtime and callback examples in its original award. The Hospitals argued that reporting time is inherently irregular. It varies with patient census and acuity, is sometimes not needed at all, and is not scheduled, so it cannot serve as a stable baseline for triggering layoffs. Like overtime, it had never been used to decide whether a layoff occurred. The Hospitals also argued that, without clarification, spending 14 minutes on TOA one day and 12 the next could be treated as a “reduction in hours of work” and trigger a layoff, with no workable way to offer bumping and recall rights.
ONA relied on Hamilton Health Sciences v ONA , but the Board found that the case did not help. The TOA described there may have referred to transferring a patient from the operating room to the post-anaesthetic unit, and in any event it played no part in the finding that no layoff had occurred. ONA pointed to no other authority. The Board added that, before its award, art. 13.01 deemed reporting time to be part of the normal daily tour, so it could not have counted separately in the layoff analysis. Counting it now would not preserve the status quo, as ONA argued. Instead, it would significantly expand layoff entitlements, contrary to the award’s intent. The parties were directed to make a consequential amendment.
Article 11 Leaves: What This Means Going Forward
The Board declined to direct any amendment because none of the art. 11 provisions in dispute refers to hours of work or “hours worked.” It held that whether paid reporting time forms part of a nurse’s “salary”, “regular pay”, “regular earnings” or “regular weekly earnings” is a question of collective agreement interpretation for a rights arbitrator. The Board expressly stated that it was expressing no view on the merits. It also refused to apply the logic of the MOA lists, because para. 6 of the MOA makes the agreement without prejudice for any provision not listed.
For employers, the question is open; it has not been decided in ONA’s favour. Hospitals should expect grievances at the local level about leave pay and pregnancy and parental SUB top-ups. How a hospital treats paid reporting time in these payroll calculations will be tested provision by provision, depending on each clause’s wording (for example, “regularly scheduled hours” in art. 11.09(c) as compared with “salary”). The Hospitals’ nominee dissented on this point, warning that leaving the question open would lead to needless time and expense in litigation.
Nurse Practitioner Grid: What This Means Going Forward
The September 2025 award set minimum NP hourly rates by “years of service” (for example, from $63.66 at Start up to $74.46 at Year 8), based on averages across the Participating Hospitals. ONA argued that “years of service” meant combined RN and NP service with the employer. It said that 21 of 127 hospitals had implemented the award that way and that about 10 grievances had been filed. The Hospitals disputed this, saying that 13 of the named hospitals had not counted RN service.
The Board clarified that it did not intend to change NP grid placement based on RN service or otherwise. Placement and progression continue to be governed by the existing collective agreement provisions, such as arts. 19.04(a), 19.05 (related clinical experience) and 19.06. The minimums are a floor, ensuring that an NP at a given step is not paid less than the sector average for that step. Hospitals can expect future grievances regarding the inclusion of RN service in the NP wage grid.
2. The Participating Hospitals v Ontario Public Service Employees’ Union (OPSEU/SEFPO)
CanLII Citation: 2026 CanLII 87471 (ON LA)
Date: August 17, 2026
Arbitrators
Colin Johnston (Chair)
Brett Christen (Hospitals Nominee)
Wassim Garzouzi (Union Nominee)
Employees Covered
The central process covers 65 bargaining units at 57 hospitals across Ontario, representing approximately 14,000 allied and paramedical employees represented by OPSEU/SEFPO. The agreement is not a central contract. It is a template agreement adopted by each participating hospital.
Duration of Collective Agreement
April 1, 2025 – March 31, 2027 (two-year term)
What Was Awarded
- General wage increases of 3.00% effective April 1, 2025, and 2.25% effective April 1, 2026.
- A new Registered Respiratory Therapist (RRT) grid, with Year 8 set at $56.00 before the general wage increase. Senior RRT and Charge RRT rates receive step increases before the 3% increase is applied, so that differentials are maintained.
- A new Perfusionist grid, with Year 5 set at $83.10 before the general wage increase. No RRT or Perfusionist will see a reduction in pay.
- Night and weekend premiums each increased by $0.10 per hour.
- Standby premium increased from $3.30 to $3.45 per hour, and from $4.90 to $5.05 per hour for designated holidays.
- Meal allowance increased from $4 to $6 per meal.
- Vision care corrected to $450. Physiotherapy, chiropractic and massage benefits increased from $300 to $450 per benefit, annually.
- The orthodontics lifetime maximum increased from $1,500 to $2,500. Crown, bridge and repair work coverage increased from $1,500 to $2,500 annually.
- A new mental health benefit of $800 annually, limited to registered psychologists, registered psychotherapists and registered social workers.
- Drug dispensing fee increased from $9 to $11.99.
- Pregnancy and parental top-up increased from 84% to 93%.
- Vacation of 5 weeks after 11 years of service (previously 12) and 7 weeks after 25 years of service (previously 27). Part-time employees receive equivalent entitlements after 18,150 and 41,250 hours of continuous service.
- Hospital proposals awarded: temporary vacancies may be filled for up to 12 months (previously 6). Extended tours language provides that agreement “will not be unreasonably denied,” but that it is not unreasonable for the Union to deny an hours-of-work agreement when employees in the affected unit vote against it. A new paragraph (h) was added to the Integration for the Delivery of Health Services LOU.
- Rejected: RN/RT parity; merger of the RT grid with the RT plus grid; restored 6% and 12% differentials for Senior and Charge RRTs; unlimited mental health benefits; contracting out restrictions; notice of artificial intelligence-related technological change; and removal of LTD arbitration.
Rationale on Wages
The Board applied the statutory factors under HLDAA and the established interest arbitration principles of total compensation, replication, comparability, demonstrated need and gradualism. It followed the sector-wide 3.00% and 2.25% wage pattern. The Board held that total compensation does not require adopting ONA’s monetary package dollar for dollar. It found that TOA was unique to ONA, because it corrected a historical anomaly under which nurses were not paid for all hours worked.
Dissents
The union nominee dissented. He argued that the Chair invoked total compensation without ever costing the package as a whole. He also argued that the LOU amendment was supported by neither demonstrated need nor a comparator. The hospitals nominee partially dissented. He argued that the package was too generous for a two-year agreement and improperly placed OPSEU/SEFPO in a “catch-up” position. He also argued that the Board should have granted the Medical Appeals Process (LTD) proposal.