This quarter’s hospital decisions turn less on wage tables than on proof and process. The COVID-19 vaccination terminations split on the ESA—Hamilton Health Sciences owed termination and severance pay, while St. Thomas Elgin, the same month, did not. An ICU nurse with 26 years of service lost her job and her ESA entitlements for overriding a physician’s medication orders. An attendance program restart ran into ESA leave protections. And three human-rights and accommodation rulings each turned on the evidence the employee did, or did not, put forward.
-
Picked-Up Shifts Count Toward Consecutive Shift Premium, but Estoppel Bars Recovery — Northumberland Hills Hospital
In a decision dated September 8, 2026, Arbitrator Jasbir Parmar upheld in part ONA grievances concerning the consecutive shift premium for nurses on a two-day/two-night (2D/2N) schedule at Northumberland Hills Hospital.
-
Performance, Not Age: HRTO Dismisses Age Discrimination Claim by Probationary Hospital Employee
The Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario dismissed an application alleging that a hospital ended a 57-year-old employee’s employment during probation because of his age. In a decision released August 20, 2026, Adjudicator Rosamaria Longo found that the employee had not shown, on a balance of probabilities, that age was a factor. She accepted the hospital’s…
-
No Duty to Post Vacated Positions During Elimination Notice Period
In an award dated July 6, 2026, Arbitrator Mitchnick dismissed two CUPE policy grievances alleging that Health Sciences North was required to post and temporarily fill vacated clerical positions during the five-month notice period for their elimination under Article 9.08A of the CUPE central agreement.
-
Just Cause Upheld, but ESA Entitlements Ordered — Hamilton Health Sciences COVID-19 Vaccination Terminations
In an award dated July 8, 2026, a Board of Arbitration chaired by John Stout found that Hamilton Health Sciences had just cause to terminate 36 CUPE-represented employees (the “grievors”) for non-compliance with its mandatory COVID-19 vaccination policy, but ordered the Hospital to pay their termination and severance pay under the Employment Standards Act, 2000…
-
Grievances First: HRTO Defers Hospital Employee’s Application over Pro-Palestine Pin
The Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario deferred a hospital employee’s discrimination application until two union grievances about the same events are concluded. In an interim decision dated July 14, 2026, Vice-Chair Rebecca Case allowed the application to continue despite concerns that it was filed late. She then put it on hold, finding that deferral was…
-
Family Status Accommodation: Arbitrator Finds Hospital Technologist’s Caregiving Requests Reflected Preferences, Not Needs
A recent Ontario arbitration award dismisses two grievances in which a long-serving hospital employee alleged he had been denied accommodation on the basis of family status. Arbitrator Wacyk adopted the test from Misetich, which requires a “real disadvantage” to a family relationship, not merely a negative impact on a family need. She concluded that the…
-
Attendance Management: Hospital Agrees to Exclude ESA-Protected COVID-19 Leave and Pause-Period Absences from Its Program
A recent Ontario arbitration decision resolves a union policy grievance challenging how a hospital restarted its Attendance Management Program (AMP) after a pandemic-era pause. The union argued that absences due to symptomatic COVID-19, and absences that occurred while the program was suspended, should not count toward enrolment or progression. Once the hospital understood that the…
-
Acting Outside Scope of Practice: Arbitrator Upholds Termination of 26-Year ICU Nurse
A recent Ontario arbitration award confirms that a nurse who deliberately departs from physician medication orders can be dismissed for just cause, even after decades of service. The award also finds that this kind of conduct can amount to “wilful misconduct,” which disentitles the employee to termination and severance pay under the Employment Standards Act,…
-
Termination and ESA Disentitlement Upheld for Vaccination Policy Non-Compliance — St. Thomas Elgin General Hospital
In an award dated July 27, 2026, Arbitrator Lindsay Lawrence dismissed a grievance challenging the termination of an Operating Room Attendant for failing to comply with St. Thomas Elgin General Hospital’s mandatory COVID-19 vaccination policy, and held that she was not entitled to termination or severance pay under the Employment Standards Act, 2000 (“ESA”).