St. Thomas Elgin General Hospital v OPSEU, Local 159, 2026 CanLII 76857 (ON LA)
Lindsay Lawrence, Arbitrator — July 27, 2026
In an award dated July 27, 2026, Arbitrator Lindsay Lawrence dismissed a grievance challenging the termination of an Operating Room Attendant for failing to comply with St. Thomas Elgin General Hospital’s mandatory COVID-19 vaccination policy, and held that she was not entitled to termination or severance pay under the Employment Standards Act, 2000 (“ESA”).
Background
The grievor had been employed with the Hospital since 2016. She was placed on an unpaid leave of absence on October 20, 2021, and was advised in person and in writing that she could return if she got vaccinated and complied with the policy but that her employment would be terminated if she did not. She was terminated on November 26, 2021, just over five weeks later.
The hospital’s evidence was that its region had among the lowest COVID-19 vaccination rates and highest per capita COVID-19 case rates in Ontario. The hospital was operating beyond capacity and facing a staffing crisis, with roughly 200 vacancies among approximately 800 employees. The Union conceded the policy was reasonable, but argued that termination was excessive, that the rievor should have remained on unpaid leave until she acquiesced or until COVID-19 was over, and that the “Code M – Dismissal” notation on her Record of Employment showed her termination was a foregone conclusion.
The Decision
Following Humber River Health v Teamsters Local Union No. 419, Arbitrator Lawrence held that non-compliance with a reasonable mandatory vaccination policy constitutes just cause for discipline.
The grievor’s termination was not excessive. Employers are not required to keep non-compliant employees on indefinite unpaid leave, and staffing shortages weigh against the imposition of unpaid leaves of absence and rather in favour of termination. Individual mitigating factors carry less weight in this context, and the grievor had received full information, repeated warnings and more than the prevailing minimum of four weeks of unpaid leave. Her respectful conduct did not outweigh these considerations, and the Record of Employment coding was not material.
Adopting Ontario Health atHome v CUPE, Local 3313 (unreported, March 4, 2026) and Render v ThyssenKrupp Elevator (Canada) Limited, Arbitrator Lawrence held that a continuing, intentional refusal to comply with a reasonable vaccination policy constitutes “wilful misconduct” under O. Reg. 288/01, disentitling the grievor to ESA termination and severance pay.
Key Takeaways for Employers
Where employees are fully informed, warned, and placed on at least four weeks of unpaid leave before termination, arbitrators are consistently upholding dismissals for vaccination policy non-compliance. This decision also confirms that such conduct can meet the ESA wilful misconduct threshold — a contrast with the Hamilton Health Sciences Corporation v CUPE, Local 7800 award released the same month, where the manner of implementation led to a different result under the ESA.