February 1, 2018
3.5 Year Jail Sentence for Supervisor Involved in Fatal Christmas Eve Swing Stage Accident Upheld on Appeal
On January 30, 2018, the Ontario Court of Appeal released its decision on the appeal against the convictions and sentence of the project manager involved in a fatal swing stage accident on Christmas Eve, 2009. Vadim Kazenelson, was the second individual to be convicted of criminal negligence under the 2004 Bill C-45 amendments to the Criminal Code which imposed specific legal duties with respect to workplace health and safety.
At trial, Kazenelson was convicted of four counts of criminal negligence causing death and one count of criminal negligence causing bodily harm after a swing stage collapsed and five workers fell more than 100 feet to the ground. The trial judge found that Kazenelson failed to take any steps to prevent workers from boarding the swing stage while knowing that there were only two lifelines available, which did not comply with a fundamental rule that fall protection is required by all workers on a swing stage because of the risk that the swing stage could fail. The trial judge found this conduct was exacerbated because Kazenelson had no information about the load capacity of the swing stage, yet allowed a total of 7 people to board along with their equipment. For the trial judge, this behaviour showed wanton and reckless disregard for the lives and safety of the workers and represented a marked departure from the standards expected of a reasonable supervisor. Consequently, Kazenelson was sentenced to 3 ½ years on each count to be served concurrently (meaning at the same time).
On appeal, Kazenelson argued that the conviction was unreasonable for two reasons: the trial judge misapplied the test for criminal negligence and the trial judge misapprehended the evidence. On sentencing, Kazenelson argued that the trial judge failed to consider the conduct of the workers, placed too much emphasis on general deterrence, and erred in finding that Kazenelson put the employer’s interests ahead of the workers.
Ultimately, the Ontario Court of Appeal rejected all of Kazenelson’s arguments and firmly supported the decision of the trial judge. It was noted that, in convicting Kazenelson, the trial judge’s reasons were clear, the test for criminal negligence was properly applied and all inferences were rooted firmly in findings of fact. With respect to sentence, the Court of Appeal rejected arguments contending that the sentence was too severe. Kazenelson argued that his moral blameworthiness should have been reduced because the workers were contributorily negligent (they didn’t use fall protection despite being aware it was required when working on a swing stage). He also argued that the sentenced imposed overemphasized general deterrence because this was a first offence and a momentary lapse in judgment. Finally, Kazenelson argued that the trial judge erred by inferring that Kazenelson had allowed unprotected workers on the swing stage because of a desire to finish the work on the day of the accident.
The significance of the Court of Appeal decision is that it entirely supports the approach and analysis of the trial judge. As such, we have little to add to our analysis of the importance of the Kazenelson case than was set out in our earlier pieces regarding the conviction and sentence. Anecdotally, since the tragic events of December 24, 2009, Criminal Code prosecutions for workplace accidents have become more frequent, against both corporations and individuals, and the trends suggest that will continue. In addition, Ontario recently implemented significant increases in maximum penalties for contraventions of its Occupational Health and Safety Act. Employers and management should treat this decision as a stark reminder of the potential human and legal consequences for failing to vigilantly comply with expected health and safety standards.
If you have any questions about this topic or any other questions relating to workplace law, please do not hesitate to contact a Mathews Dinsdale lawyer.
Click here for downloadable version.